Why do we buy if it doesn’t make economic sense?

It’s the age old question, rent or buy? New York Times writer David Leonhardt tackled this timeless issue again in his latest weekly column. As he points out, all sorts of calculators live on the web for anyone to input a few data points to analyze whether it’s better to buy or rent. However, most of these calculators look at it from a purely financial perspective, whether the costs of buying outweigh the costs of renting. Some calculators are more sophisticated, taking into account often overlooked items such as closing costs, property taxes and the amount of interest or appreciation your down payment would have otherwise earned, if it wasn’t used towards a home purchase.

Miami Real Estate Cafe

The never ending debate

He also advises look at rent ratios, where the selling price of a house is divided by the yearly cost to rent an equivalent property. Fifteen is the magic number with rent ratios. Below 15, he advises buying over renting. Rent ratios in most of the Bay Area are still looking “bubbly,” coming in above 30 down in Silicon valley and the East Bay. In San Francisco, the rent ratio is currently at 27, still above 15 but at least closer to its 1986-2000 average of 24. The average rent ratio for the 1990-2000 East Bay and Silicon Valley was 26 and 23, meaning it has gotten more and more expensive to buy, though it’s less expensive now than in 2005 when the housing market was peaking. The rent ratios in 2005 were 47, 43 and 40 for the East Bay, Silicon Valley and San Francisco. So if it doesn’t make economic sense, why do people still keep buying?

Affluent people tend to want to own their houses, even when the dollars don’t make sense, and the Northeast and West Coast are home to much more wealth than a few decades ago.

Yet the fact remains that a lot of New Yorkers and Californians, among others, are paying a hefty premium for the privilege of owning.

A while back, readers commented on this blog that being a homeowner was a way to deal with non performing landlords. How much is that worth economically? Leonhardt says that our area is still in a state of “real estate exuberance,” but that given our current behavior and trends, it may survive.

How do you evaluate the costs of buying vs. renting? Did you buy even if it didn’t make economic sense?

For a full list of rent ratios, click here.

Posted By: Jenny Pisillo (Email) | May 13 2011 at 01:00 PM

del.icio.us
Digg
Technorati
Reddit
LinkedIn
Facebook